Hotwire Hotel: Looking for 3* + in NYC December 21-23

[the midwesten]

I am looking to book a room for two nights in Manhattan December 21-23. I have looked on Hotwire a few times and things change daily. I think at this point we would consider Chelsea, Empire State, or one of the Midtowns. Soho (on Hotwire) seems to include too much area to really consider. I know I can book a Hampton Inn for $111, so I would like to do better then that.

Right now I am looking at a 3.5* in Chelsea - Madison Square Garden. $98. Amenities are: Restaurant, Fitness, Hi-Speed and Business. Sounds like the Doubletree, but since the Doubletree books at $199 a night, I doubt that is correct (50% off??).

Any way to get more confidence in what hotel it might be or suggestions in general to get a sweet deal? (sub - $100)

Thanks,

Fred.

PS. Typically I use Priceline, but for smaller cities. NYC seems to have more risk. Things rated 3 stars seem to get some pretty bad reviews online, so I am a bit fearful of pulling the trigger. Should I be? If I did use Priceline, what should I bid? $75 for 3.5*?

[thereuare]

Welcome to BetterBidding!

If you haven't yet, please start by reading your messages.

The Chelsea-MSG property above matches both the Ramada New Yorker and the Doubletree, so either of these would be a likely outcome (and the Ramada is typically seen more frequently then the Doubletree... although you should be prepared for either)

PRICELINE vs. HOTWIRE comes down to a trade-off between the lowest possible price vs. having more of a comfort level in the hotel you will be awarded. PRICELINE is usually cheaper than HOTWIRE, but HOTWIRE gives you known amenities, a guess as to which property you may receive, and a percent recommendation by previous HOTWIRE guests (which can give a bit of comfort in making your purchase).

You may be able to get a 4* hotel on PRICELINE for ~$120 or so if you're willing to stretch your budget a bit further, otherwise it comes down to your comfort level vs. your budget.

Let us know how you'd like to proceed and we'll advise accordingly.

Please use the PRICELINE and HOTWIRE links on the board to begin your travel purchases.