The only way to answer your question for sure is to bid up to your limit. There is a $127 Long Island 2* on Hotwire with free breakfast and 60% recommended. That suggests a bid of $120 might be successful. There is no set difference between bidding and the semi-opaque deals of Priceline Express and Hotwire. There are instances of no savings, but generally there is some. 5% ... 10% ... ?
The three Priceline reported Long Island City 2* hotels are the Comfort Inn, the Quality Inn and the Sleep Inn. Only one is reviewed here and the reviewer was OK with it. I looked at the three on Tripadvisor. One got a 3 1/2 and the other two got 4s for reviews. Fairly positive. The thing is that one can always receive an as yet unreported hotel, and the 2* level can be dicey.
FYI, I'm a member, not a board official, so keep that in mind in what I have to say.
Technically for bidding Long Island at the 2* level, you would only get one bid a day and you don't have a lot of time. But you can have more bids if you simply add in those zones you know are most likely too expensive but you'd be OK with if you happened to get them. You mentioned 4 besides Long Island. So you could do something like start LI at $108, then add in the other 4 one at a time while bidding 111, 114, 117 and 120.
Or you can accept the $127 Hotwire deal, valuing that free breakfast and the decent recommendations at $7.
You might wait to see what thereuare or one of the other administrators has to add. Often my ideas get refined a bit for the better.
Romelle