I have been charged a resort fee at the Moano Surfrider, the Hyatt and the Marriott. I saw that someone else did not pay resort fee at the Hyatt, but I certainly did every time that I said there. If you are planning to get a car, make sure that you also check the parking fees, as $25/day adds up. I can't confirm if the posted list is complete, but I will say that I have stayed in Waikiki (resort) many times and I always received a hotel that is on the BB list. I have read the same thing, but that absolutely has not been my case. I've used priceline quite a bit and have never been put in a small or dirty room. Granted, most of the time I don't get the best views, but IMHO I would rather save $100 or so per night and have a parking lot/mountain view. Call me a snob, but when I go to Hawaii I now only stay at resorts. I would not consider anything else. I once stayed at a 3.5*, and for me it took away from the vacation experience. I want to be either right on the beach or right across the street. I guess it depends on what you want out of your vacation. I want convenient beach access and a nice pool area. Walking 10 minutes to the beach doesn't cut it for me. BTW, I think what room you get has a lot to do with the attitude that you portray at check in. If you are kind and polite, you will tend to do better. It depends on what you want out of your vacation. I've already established that I am somewhat a Hawaii snob, so I personally would not stay anywhere else in Waikiki, except Waikiki Beach. If I could not get a reasonable win at Waikiki Beach, then I would go to a different part of the island like the North Shore or the Ko Olina. The advantage of Waikiki Beach is that you have the beach at your disposal and the night life all conveniently located. I always call the hotel in advance (as soon as I win). I have not had a problem with late check in. Early check in is more of a problem. The one problem that you may have with a late check in is room availability - IOW, less rooms means less opportunity to get placed in a "good" room. Not sure.One more thing, unless you are a "night life" kind of person, I would recommend staying on a different part of the island for some of your stay. Don't get me wrong, I love Waikiki (my wife does not), but 3-4 days is plenty for my liking. Oahu is just so diverse and a drive to the North Shore is not the same as staying up there - it's just a different lifestyle. I guess it depends on what you want to do on Oahu. If you want to do all the touristy things, then being based out of Waikiki Beach is OK. If you are looking for relaxation, then I think you would be better off going to the North Shore (Turtle Bay) or Ko Olina.