2.5* Holdiay Inn Express Amenities: Complimentary Breakfast, Pool, Fitness, Hi-Speed Internet, Business, Laundry This is now a 3* hotel according to Hotwire. I know because it put me there :/
I ended doing something similiar for a trip in San Fran. I only need the car for 4 days but ended up getting a good price difference at 6. After booking I called the rental car company and asked if I would get the same rate if I had to return the car early. They said the rate would stay the same and I wouldn't be charged for the extra days. Even if I got charged for the two extra days the trip was significantly cheaper. Disclaimer: I have not actually taken the trip so I can't confirm this is true with a bill in my hand. :)
We stayed at this hotel for our anniversary. We only stayed for a night and the place was nice. Right on the water. Go to Mama Luisa's. Great Italian food.