As long as the 3* would not place us in an uncomfortable spot in terms of safety, I would definitely consider it. This is our first trip to NYC, so our biggest concern is safety, not luxury. Also, our stay could be cut down by one night to leave on the 25th. Ideally, we could stay in mid-town for at least four nights even if the hotel is not as upscale. I would consider splitting the trip up as well. Thanks, again.