I stayed her a little over a year ago at New Year's. I loved my room. I had a room overlooking the intersection of Broadway and Amsterdam and could see the Lincoln Center patrons walk the steps to their evenings show at the opera or the symphony or the theatre. I liked my room a lot. And as a boutique designed hotel I'd give you this advice. Don't call and ask about the missing shower curtains. Just accept them as not being there, and make puddles. That's what a friend told me, and I did just that. I think you landed a fine hotel. And go to bar before you go to your room to ask the hours of the oyster specials. I know I had a few Goose Island Stouts with Oysters on that visit.