Hi, I thoroughly checked all of the reviews that I could find, and closely examined the neighborhood, and depending on where you looked, the Murray Hills East Suites is rated 3* by sites such as Expedia and Travel Advisor. PL ranks it a 2*. Let's not split hairs...Based upon the reviews, ranking from other sites, and after talking to someone I know who stayed there, I am going to consider this hotel a 2.5* and possibly a minimal 3* as you thought. This (my) rating might go up or down after my stay is complete, but if 99% of the reviewers are right, it will probably not go down to a 2*. Perhaps PL goes by the old adage of "under promise and over deliver"! I am sure that you have noticed the disparity of star ratings between the different sites such as PL and Hotwire, etc. My personal experience also has shown me that what some people would consider a 3* is actually a 4* and vice versa. Star ratings are like personal preferences for food, cars, clothing, homes, hobbies, etc., and are very subjective! When I travel, I do not spend alot of time in my room anyway, so my hotel is used mainly for sleeping and bathing. I am always pleasantly suprised with so-called 3* hotels, that are in excellent condition, with excellent service, in excellent locations. Resort type services and amenities are usually lost on me. The Murray Hill East Suites looks like a good find formy purposes. By the way I bid 5*, 4* & 3* up to $180 in UES, UWS, UMT/CPS, without success, then I started to bid 2.5* and 2* in MTE, MTW starting at $150 without success, and when I finally bid in MTS @ $170 I was successful. Perhaps if I had started in MTS @ $150 or lower I would have been successful sooner, but I have to be in NYC on 6-9. Learning experience! If I had more time my strategy would be to start bidding 2.5* to 2* in MTS, then UES, UWS, UMT/CPS, finally moving to MTW. MTE and SOHO if necessary. I also tried using various conbinations like one and two day reservations without success for 5, 4, and 3* hotels. Not available. By the way, in doing my research I noticed a 1* HOJO right near CPS that might be picked up at a decent price. Great neighborhood, and hotel was just renovated. Anyway, I can't complain after all of the 3*, 4* and resort stays that I have obtained for $60 to $35 dollars! By the way the hotel address is as follow: Murray Hill East Suite Hotel 149 East 39th Street New York, New York 10016 United States 212-661-2100 This hotel should not be confused with Murray Hill Shelburne which is close by, as you mentioned, and is a 4*hotel, if I am not mistaken. Murray Hill East Suites is near the UN, and Grand Central Station, and just 1.5 miles SE of Central park. Murray Hill is simply the name of the residential neighborhood that the hotels lie in.