Thank you SO much for your detailed advice! I ended up going with Bryant Park and indeed I got Omni Berkshire Place.
For what it's worth, the promo code BBJAN2019 was not accepted. The total (with $10 protection fee) came out to $330.34 for a "King Bed Deluxe Room" for the two weekend nights. I'm sure it's a good deal for a 4.5 star hotel in the middle of NYC.
Thanks again, you are doing the Lord's work here, lol. Go Blue! 😉