Thanks for the reply, thereuare!
I only saw that offer for a few hours yesterday, but if it dropped any more I was going to jump on it. It looks like today it's going for $200/night.
We have a hotel (Fairfield Queensboro Bridge) booked for this trip already, but I've been checking on PRICELINE EXPRESS for deals that might land us closer to midtown Manhattan, even though it doesn't look like we're that far away in Long Island City. We're not interested in staying in Times Square, but somewhere midtown with close transportation (subway, primarily), some restaurants/cafes, and where we'll feel safe is all we're really looking for. It will be my first trip back to NY since I was a kid, so I want to feel like we're in NY without all of the tourist noise from Times Square. Sorry if that's not much info to go on!
Assuming taxes and fees for this stay will be around $180 (total), I think the nightly rate (max) would be $160, although we'd love to beat that so we can spend more money on food/shows/etc. I'm not averse to using NYOP, if I have some guidance from you all. I'd like to stay in 3.5* or 4*, if at all possible. Would accept a 3* if recommended from any of you all.
Thanks for any help you can provide!