Thanks for the response! I'm going with my wife and would ideally like someplace nice with some character. We used to live in the Time Square/Hell's Kitchen area so that area has some nostalgic appeal for my wife. However, many of the Times Square hotels are a little generic for the price. Consequently, I've been focusing on 5* properties in that zone with the hope that I would get a distinctive property. We'd also like to stay someplace central with reasonably good access to subways. The Royalton is a nice option (convenient with some character) that I will consider seriously. We'd also be willing to stay someplace like SoHo as long as the hotel is close to subways. I've bid on Priceline (name your own price) up to $385 for a 5* in the Times Square area with no luck (they recently had a 7% off promotion). I'm intrigued by the 5* in the Times Square zone on Hotwire. The only 5* hotels that are in that zone appear to be the Chatwal and Knickerbocker, both of which would be great (the Sofitel looks just outside the zone), but I worry that I would get something else (like a 4.5* that was recently upgraded). I don't care that much about particular amenities, so I'm almost willing to take the Hotwire deal just based on the star rating and location. However, I wish there was a recommendation rating just to make sure I wasn't going somewhere with bad service. Anyways, any thoughts would be appreciated. Great site!