johnyo24

After conferring with my wife, location became the critical factor. When I saw a 4.5* in Central Park South for $235, I decided it was time to pull the trigger. I was 99% sure that it was the Essex House based upon the discount suggested 21% (had seen Marriott had dropped the rate to $299), as well as the amenities. Amenities: Restaurant, Fitness, Non-Smoking Rooms, Pets Allowed Room Choice: Queen ($235), King ($415), King with park view ($513)

Thanks for the reply! For Hotwire Easy - Union Square, 4* for $203, I'm still seeing the same options (link: <dead link removed>) - seems like it's probably Park South? Hope to hear back from you. I'll make a decision shortly using your links and let you know where I netted out. Thanks!

Appreciate the clarifications! Main concerns on the Kitano came as I read through some reviews: beds (being extra soft) and smoke scent. My wife is pregnant so both of those things would be problematic for her having an enjoyable stay. Bernic seems great. The other two not quite up to what I was hoping for. Noted on the likely $ level needed to get 5* bid accepted. Given that it's been a few days, here's a breakdown of options currently on the table... I'm hoping to make a decision in the next few hours. Thanks again for your help... Hotwire Easy - Chelsea, 4.5*, $252 (Innside Nomad?) Free Internet, Pet friendly, Boutique hotel, Airport shuttle, Smoke-free rooms, Fitness center, Restaurant(s), Business center, Internet access Hotwire Easy - Union Square, 4*, $203 (???) Free Internet, Boutique hotel, Fitness center, Restaurant(s), Business center, Internet access, Accessible path of travel, In-room accessibility, Accessible bathroom Hotwire Easy - Union Square, 4.5*, $234 (Hotel Chandler?) Free Internet, Boutique hotel, Smoke-free rooms, Fitness center, Restaurant(s), Business center, Self-service laundry, Internet access, Golf nearby, Spa services, Accessible for visually impaired, Accessible for hearing impaired, In-room accessibility, Accessible bathroom, Accessible parking, Roll-in shower Priceline Express - Empire State Building, 4*, $200 (Marcel at Grammercy?) - Free Internet, No Smoking Rooms, Bed Choice available (largest is a queen) Priceline Express - Chelsea, 4.5*, $244 (also the Innside Nomad?) Fitness Center, Restaurant, Business Center, No Smoking Rooms/Facilities

Sorry for conjoining the threads as I searched. Meant to put the Priceline thread over in that forum. Nonetheless, appreciate your help. The Kitano has me a little concerned because I'm worried the unique aspects specific to Japanese culture may not be exactly what we are looking for. If it was Archer or Gansevoort it would be totally great, but doesn't seem to be. Desired budget: Less than $250 per night before taxes Acceptable zones: Chelsea, Empire State Building, Grand Central, Central Park South, Rockefeller Center, Union Square - East Village (basically anything midtown or higher in Manhattan) Other: looking for a nice place with comfortable King bed Also tried some bids last night for 5* on Priceline, but no success up to $250. Will try that again tonight before I hear back from you. Thanks in advance for your help!

12/28-12/31 PRICELINE EXPRESS, 4.5*, Empire State Building, $230 They are giving limited information, only: Business Center, Restaurant, and Non-Smoking Any idea? Your list only includes 2 hotels (Archer + Gansevoort), but there comps show the Chandler as well.

Hi, Looking for help identifying this 4* in the Grand Central area. Price currently shows as $247. Free Internet, Boutique Hotel, Smoke-Free Rooms, Fitness Center, Restaurants(s), Business Center, Children's Activity Staying 3 nights from 12/28-12/31. Any idea? Thanks in advance

Thanks again for all your help. Just wanted to clarify that I used the link from the site to take me to Hot.wire! Best, John

Thanks for all your help. Those were great options. As we looked at those options and the price, we ended up seeing a 5* in the Financial district for $217 a night. Sounded more spacious than any of the other options. So we ended up going with that and it was the Conrad New York. Dates 12/28 - 12/31 Price $217 5* Pet friendly, Smoke-free rooms, Fitness center, Restaurant(s), Business center, Self-service laundry, Internet access, Accessible for hearing impaired, Accessible path of travel, In-room accessibility, Wheelchair accessible, Accessible bathroom, Roll-in shower Please let me know if there's anything else we can do to help the community. Thanks again for your assistance.

Thanks so much for the detailed follow up. We don't have to stay downtown, was just looking at good value options. Residence Inn isn't exactly what we're looking for. Would prefer to stay in a place with more action (Soho-Tribeca, ESB, Times Square, Chelsea, Midtown Central/East) - totally open to suggestions. We want to have good food options and be close to public transportation lines. Currently seeing a 4.5* MSG - Hell's Kitchen Boutique for the same dates (12/28-31) for $194 Amenities: Free Internet, Pet friendly, Boutique hotel, Smoke-free rooms, Fitness center, Restaurant(s), Business center, Self-service laundry, Internet access, Spa services, Accessible for visually impaired, Accessible for hearing impaired, Accessible path of travel, In-room accessibility, Accessible bathroom, Roll-in shower Says 100% recommend, but then it says that not enough reviews have been collected. Doesn't look like there are currently any 4.5* for that area on the site. Any help? Ideally, would not want to spend more than $230-$250 per night (pre tax). Definitely appreciate your insights/suggestions. Thanks, J

Thanks for the prompt reply. I also wanted to check on the following possibility for the same dates. 4* Financial District NYC $176 (normally $351) 90% recommend Free Internet, Smoke-free rooms, Fitness center, Restaurant(s), Business center, Self-service laundry, Internet access, In-room accessibility, Wheelchair accessible Any thoughts? Doubletree? Worldcenter?

100% recommendation Free Internet, Fitness center, Restaurant(s), Business center, Internet access $201 per night; says 39% off (standard rate is $331 per night) Trying to determine what hotel this may be. From the forum it appears that it may be the Roosevelt? Thanks!