idansha

Thanks! Decided to split. got New York Hilton Midtown for 118, for 8/21-8/25 but still stuck on the first 2 dates, for some reason expensive dates.

I meant that to me the first tier is worth 150, the second is worth 130 and every one after worth less.. Is the half star makes a big difference in quality?

Sorry, i'm not decisive enough.. I'm willing to go up to 150 a nite at max for a 3.5*. Looking to get the best deal up to that price. I'm willing to go down a tier if it reduces 20$ a nite You commented that splitting won't give me significantly better deal (20$ a nite difference) so I won't go for that. (Yes, meant ESB)

Ok, so updated list (I can prioritize and add least-favored as re-bids, right?) tier 1 - Chelsea, CPS, tier 2 - Midtown east, midtown west, Times Square tier 3 - EMS, MSG tier 4 - union square

I'm slightly familiar. ESB is also possible. Hell's kitchen has bad reputation and MSG proximity to there, combined with my unexplained preference to east (other than Chelsea) throw me off that. MTE is acceptable. if splitting is not game changer I agree that it's preferable to avoid that. I'm up for your suggestions :)

Regarding areas: Prefer: Chelsea, Central Park South Acceptable: Midtown east, midtown west, times square Stars: 3.5 (even 3 if you say downfall isn't big and that it's private bathrooms for certain) Would much rather go down to the 130 prices.. would you recommend bidding 130-140 for first part and 120-130 for last part? or you suspect it won't work more of anecdote but the 8/24-8/25 has great prices

Thanks for quick reply. Some of the nights I saw there's midtown express deal for 140 and some were 170 so thought splitting would help (on last night there express deal for 100!) I already got plane tickets so I'll take whatever cheapest offer :) Is midtown cheaper than Chelsea and south the park? Will try to look for those shared bathrooms, couldn't find them either but girlfriend swears on them :)

Hello, I'm looking for 3.5* hotel. I guess my last minute strategy backfired on me a bit. So I'm willing to split the time to 2 different hotels if necessary Goal is: 110 a nite, willing up to 130$ a nite. Prefer 4* but willing to go 3.5 (girlfriend saw some express deals for 3* that include shared bathrooms and got scared off that). Prefer: Chelsea, Central Park South Acceptable: Midtown east, midtown west, times square Thanks in Advance for any help!