I went ahead and booked the 4.5* option at $181/night and it was indeed the James Hotel. Amenities listed: Free Internet, Pet friendly, Boutique hotel, Fitness center, Restaurant(s), Business center, Internet access, Spa services, Accessibility, Accessible for visually impaired, Accessible for hearing impaired, Accessible path of travel, In-room accessibility, Accessible bathroom, Accessible parking, Roll-in shower If you can provide any suggestions on what to do that would be great. We love walking around and exploring, finding hidden gems and checking out local shops, galleries, and the off-the-beaten-track places - like unique coffee shops, pubs, restaurants, etc. We love our coffee (but not Starbucks - we can get that at home!) Everyone says you have to try the deep dish pizza but we actually prefer thin-crust pizza (my wife loves Margarita pizza). We tend to like smaller restaurants like bistros and we're not really into a lot of rich food. We both enjoy wine and trying new cocktails. For breakfast all we really need is a bakery with fresh croissants and other pastries. A city tour would be of definite interest, as would a Broadway show. Thanks again for all the help, looking forward to our first visit!