I ended up taking a bit of a gamble and bidding on Price.line even though it was risky that we might end up in a boutique hotel without 2 beds. I also was not super strategic in my bidding, I just wanted below the best price Hot.wire had to offer ($303/night).
I won Sheraton in SOHO at $275 and that was my first bid! I'm happy with this, as I know they have 2 bed rooms available. Also, great reviews too.