We recently had our lodging plans altered at the last minute (private rental no longer available) and are in dire need of a hotel in and around Midtown. We are flying into LGA on 10/22 for a concert at Madison Sq. Gardens on 10/23 and leaving 10/24. I have tried the Priceline bidding strategies suggested for 4* MTE, MTW, TS, EPS, etc up to $155 with no luck. A 3* or 3.5* would suffice but I have seen rates for the Grand Hyatt ranging from $111-140 for similar dates. We want to be close to MSG if possible so we don't have so far to commute. Any help will be appreciated.