Hi! I go to New York quite a bit, here are my thoughts. I don't think there are any comparisons between the" Mandarin" and the" W Time Square"...I think the Mandarin is a much nicer property. The Mandarin is a more traditional hotel and is located in the new "Time Warner" building so therre is plenty of shopping,restaurants.....Centarl Park is also right there. The W hotels are very nice, but very trendy and from my experiences the rooms are a little small. The "70 Park Ave "is a beautiful small hotel , a Kimpton Hotel ,in Murray Hill. It is a quiet, more residential neighborhood. It is also a very trendy hotel, small lobby and small rooms, but very nice. There is nothing more romantic than having a drink in the lobby bar of the Mandarin...it is beautiful with a great view!! A great web site to get all the info you need on hotels is www.tripadvisor.com. Also www.nymag.com is great web site for what is "happening " in New York. And lastly.......Jersey Boys is a great, very fun show!! Have fun!! Robin