Given that Cabana Bay was probably out of the question for the price range I was looking for, I ended up using the HOTWIRE link to book my stay at Holiday Inn and Suites Orlando Universal Studios for $74 a night. Since there were no other hotels that fit the amenity set and TripAdvisor review score/number of reviews, I knew it had to be that one.
So still in walking distance and a hotel that has a lot of great reviews.
Free parking, Free Internet, Pet friendly, Smoke-free rooms, Fitness center, Pool(s), Restaurant(s), Business center, Self-service laundry, Internet access, Golf nearby