I gave the bidding a try to see if I could get anything closer to my price range. Here's my process: Bid 1: $135/night, Midtown East, Central Park South, Midtown West, Chelsea...Rejected Bid 2: $145/night, MTE, CPS, MTW, Ch, added long island as my bid dummy...Rejected Bid 3: $155/night, MTE, CPS, MTW, Ch, another bid dummy...Rejected For some reason it gave me a 4th attempt, even though I thought I read you can only get two re-bids on NYC. Bid 4: $162/night, same as above, but added Hell's Kitchen My bid was accepted, and I got the Hilton Manhattan East. All-in price, with trip insurance to be safe, was $608, so I came in just at my desired price point, and it ended up being slightly better deal(about 50 bucks) than if I would have done PRICELINE EXPRESS 4* with the 10% off discount code. Thanks for the help!