I am travelling to NYC the exact same dates, also 3 people. When I check Hotwire it didn't give me anything in the theatre district. The most promising is 4* Midtown South at $312 per night, which seems to fit the 70 Park description. Would priceline have a better deal? Did you purchase the 3.5* one?
3* Williamsburg (Historic-Busch Gardens) Crowne Plaza
in Priceline Hotels - Virginia
Posted
I tried several days earlier at lower bids in Colonial Williamsburg and kept losing. Added the other area and increased bid. My first priceline win. Hopefully it will be a good experience.