I’m looking for a hotel for 5 night stay – 4/17 thru 4/22. I'm hoping you can help me narrow down these 2 hotels.
4* Gramercy Park – Nomad – Flatiron $177 that has the following amenity set: Boutique, Restaurant, Fitness, Smoke Free, Free Internet, Hi-Speed Internet, Pet Friendly. It has a 85% recommendation rate. The resort fee is $26/room. (The bidding helper narrowed this down to Ace Hotel New York, The Roger New York, Arlo Nomad, or the Freehand New York) However, I don't think that matches the number of Tripadvisor reviews for these properties.
4* Madison Square Garden $178 that has the following amenity set: Restaurant, Fitness, Smoke Free, Free Internet, Hi-Speed Internet, Business, Room Accessible, Bathroom Accessible, Roll-in Shower, Pet Friendly. It has a 95% recommendation rate. The resort fee is $34/room. (The bidding helper narrowed this down to a best guess of the Crowne Plaza HY36 Midtown. The board actually helped me to get this hotel last year! It’s very nice, but I’d prefer to be a little further south. I'm kind of hesitant due to the $34 resort fee.)
I'm not against other districts if you see an outstanding property for those dates that you'd suggest. I just don't want to be in Times Square or further north than Times Square. I'd like to stay at around $200. I’m also comfortable with Priceline if there is a better deal there.
THANKS IN ADVANCE