I sounds to me what this guy did is book a hotel on hotwire and the research it on Orbitz or Expedia or Travelocity and they rate it differnt. Now I am not a lawyer, but if the hotel that was booked has the ammenity's that were listed and matched the discription of a 5 star on there web site the suit has no merit. In the end star rating are subjective there is no standard, I could rate a Motel 6 a 5 star but the guy in the next room could rate it a 1 star! Also the 185 4.5 star could have been 600/per night 2 days later.