i can see 2 good options.
1 at hotwire (3.5-star Hotel in Times Square South area, 90% recommendation, 4/5 trip advisor . full amenities:Free Internet, Smoke-free rooms, Fitness center, Restaurant(s), Business center, Internet access)
1 priceline offer (3,5-star Times Square - Theatre District Area, 8+ rating, amenities: fitness and business center, only)
Maybe is the same hotel.