Welcome to Betterbidding.
Personally, I'd take the 4* on HOTWIRE in the Midtown West-Theater District for $115 (you may see a slightly different price) w/Boutique, Restaurant, Fitness, Smoke Free, Free Internet, Hi-Speed Internet, Business, Blind Accessible, Travel Accessible, Room Accessible, Bathroom Accessible, Wheelchair Accessible, Handicapped Parking, Roll-in Shower.
>>> This is possible match for the Yotel Times Square. You can see a 4.5/5 tripadvisor rating on the detail page for the HOTWIRE listing. This is a well-reviewed property and at about $615, is under budget and under pretty much all of the other 4* midtown offerings on HOTWIRE for these dates. Additionally, September is traditionally not a slow month in NYC.
Would this be of interest? You could also try and bid, but I don't think you could get something for much less and you may not get something that has a 4.5/5 tripadvisor rating.
Please remember to return to BetterBidding and use the PRICELINE and HOTWIRE links on the board to begin your travel purchases... or thru our sister site MAPSandHOTELS.com for your regular rate purchases.
Let us know how you'd like to proceed (or how it goes if you take the HOTWIRE offer above) and we'll take it from there.